Dan J. Harkey

Master Educator | Business & Finance Consultant | Mentor

The Complete Herding Dog Training Guide: Training My Dog, Daisy Jane

From Puppy Basics to Advanced Herding Skills

by Dan J. Harkey

Share This Article

Chapter 1: Introduction to Herding Dogs

Herding dogs are among the most intelligent and instinct-driven breeds in the canine world.  Historically bred to assist shepherds and farmers, these dogs excel at controlling and moving livestock.  Today, they are not only working partners but also beloved companions and competitive athletes.

Common Herding Breeds:

  • Border Collie
  • Australian Shepherd
  • Old English Sheepdog
  • Shetland Sheepdog
  • Belgian Malinois
  • German Shepherd (dual-purpose)

Chapter 2: Understanding Herding Instincts

Herding behavior is a modified predatory instinct.  Instead of chasing and killing prey, herding dogs have been bred to control movement.

This instinct manifests as:

  • Circling or flanking
  • “Eyeing” livestock
  • Nipping at heels
  • Anticipating movement

Key Insight: Even when acting as pets, herding dogs may attempt to herd children, other pets, or even cars.  Training channels these instincts productively.

Chapter 3: Preparing for Training

Before starting herding work:

  • Equipment Needed: Long lead, whistle, herding balls, treats.
  • Environment: Safe, enclosed area for early sessions.
  • Health Check: Ensure your dog is fit for high-energy work.

Chapter 4: Foundation Training

Start with obedience:

  • Essential Commands: Sit, Stay, Come, Down, Heel.
  • Socialization: Expose your dog to people, animals, and environments.
  • Focus Building: Use short sessions and positive reinforcement.

Chapter 5: Channeling Energy and Instinct

Herding dogs need jobs:

  • Structured Play: Fetch, frisbee, tug-of-war.
  • Herding Balls: Mimic livestock movement.
  • Mental Games: Puzzle toys, scent work, and advanced commands.

Chapter 6: Advanced Herding Techniques

Once obedience is solid:

  • Introducing Livestock: Start with calm sheep in a small pen.
  • Directional Commands:
    • Come By (clockwise)
    • Away to Me (counterclockwise)
    • Lie Down (stop and wait)
  • Whistle Training: For distance control.
  • Gradual Complexity: Increase flock size and open space.

Chapter 7: Troubleshooting Common Issues

  • Overexcitement: Use a calm voice and structured breaks.
  • Nipping: Redirect with toys and commands.
  • Ignoring Commands: Reinforce obedience before herding.

Chapter 8: Lifestyle and Care

  • Exercise: 1–2 hours daily.
  • Nutrition: High-protein diet for working dogs.
  • Grooming: Regular brushing for double coats.
  • Mental Health: Avoid boredom, provide jobs and stimulation.

Chapter 9: Beyond the Farm

Herding dogs excel in:

  • Dog Sports: Agility, obedience, and herding trials.
  • Service Roles: Therapy, assistance dogs.
  • Family Life: Great companions for active households.

Chapter 10: Resources

  • Books & Videos: Herding training manuals.
  • Organizations: American Herding Breed Association (AHBA).
  • Training Programs: Local herding clubs and online courses.

Expanded Chapter 4: Foundation Training:

Chapter 4: Foundation Training – Building Obedience and Focus

Before introducing your herding dog to livestock or advanced commands, you must establish a strong foundation of obedience and trust.  This stage is critical because herding work requires precise control at a distance, and without basic training, your dog may become frustrated, overexcited, or even injure animals.

Why Foundation Training Matters

Herding dogs are brilliant and instinct-driven.  While these traits make them excellent workers, they can also lead to impulsive behavior if not properly managed.

Foundation training:

  • Create a communication system between you and your dog.
  • Build trust and respect.
  • Prevents undesirable behaviors such as chasing, nipping, or ignoring commands.

Step 1: Essential Commands

Start with these core commands:

  • Sit – Teaches impulse control.
  • Stay – Helps maintain position until released.
  • Come – Critical for recall during herding.
  • Down – Used to stop movement instantly.
  • Heel – Keeps your dog close when walking.

Training Tips:

  • Use short sessions (5–10 minutes) to maintain your dog’s engagement.
  • Reward with treats, praise, and Play immediately after correct behavior.
  • Practice in a distraction-free environment before moving to open spaces.

Step 2: Socialization

Expose your dog to:

  • People and Animals – Prevent fear or aggression.
  • Different Environments – Fields, barns, and noisy areas.
  • Controlled Livestock Encounters – Let your dog observe sheep from a distance before interacting with them.

Goal: A calm, confident dog that can focus on tasks without anxiety.

Step 3: Building Focus

Herding dogs are easily distracted by movement.

Teach focus through:

  • Eye Contact Exercises – Reward your dog when they look at you on command.
  • Name Recognition – Reinforce response to their name.
  • Impulse Control Games – “Wait” before eating or chasing a toy.

Step 4: Positive Reinforcement

  • Always reward desired behavior immediately.
  • Use high-value treats for new or complex commands.
  • Avoid punishment—herding dogs respond best to encouragement.

Step 5: Gradual Progression

Once your dog masters basic commands:

  • Increase distance and distractions.
  • Practice commands in open fields.
  • Introduce long-line training for recall and control.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Skipping Basics – Herding without obedience leads to chaos.
  • Overlong sessions cause fatigue and frustration.
  • Inconsistent Commands – Always use the exact words and tone.

Chapter 5: Channeling Energy and Instinct – Giving Your Herding Dog a Job

Herding dogs are bred for action.  Their instincts drive them to regulate movement, anticipate directional changes, and remain alert for hours.  Without proper outlets, these traits can lead to frustration, destructive behavior, or obsessive tendencies.  This chapter focuses on how to channel that energy productively—whether you live on a farm or in a suburban home.

Why Channeling Instincts Matters

Herding dogs are not content to sit idle.

They need:

  • Physical exercise to burn energy.
  • Mental stimulation to satisfy their intelligence.
  • Purposeful tasks to fulfill their working heritage.

When these needs are met, herding dogs become calm, focused, and happy companions.  When ignored, they may herd children, chase cars, or chew furniture.

Step 1: Structured Physical Exercise

Daily exercise is non-negotiable:

  • Fetch and Frisbee – Great for speed and agility.
  • Jogging or hiking builds stamina and strengthens the bond.
  • Agility Courses – Jumps, tunnels, and weave poles mimic herding challenges.

Recommendation: Aim for 60–90 minutes of vigorous activity daily.

Step 2: Herding Balls and Alternative Activities

If you don’t have livestock:

  • Herding Balls – Large, durable balls designed for dogs to push and control.
  • Treibball – A sport where dogs herd balls into a goal, simulating livestock work.
  • Controlled Chase Games – Teach your dog to chase and stop on command.

Goal: Satisfy the instinct to control movement without livestock.

Step 3: Mental Stimulation

Herding dogs are problem-solvers.

Keep their minds sharp:

  • Puzzle Toys – Hide treats inside for them to figure out.
  • Scent Work – Teach them to find hidden objects by smell.
  • Advanced Commands – Beyond “sit” and “stay,” add directional cues like:
    • Come By (clockwise)
    • Away to Me (counterclockwise)
    • Lie Down (stop and wait)

Tip: Rotate activities to prevent boredom.

Step 4: Incorporate Herding Instincts into Play

  • Use controlled movement games where your dog circles you or objects on command.
  • Practice stop-and-go drills to mimic herding pauses.
  • Reward calm behavior after excitement—this teaches impulse control.

Step 5: Social Interaction

Herding dogs thrive on teamwork:

  • Play interactive games with family members.
  • Join herding clubs or dog sports groups for structured activities.
  • Consider herding trials if you have access to livestock.

Common Mistakes

  • Overexercising without mental work – Physical activity alone won’t satisfy a herding dog.
  • Ignoring instinctual needs leads to behavioral problems.
  • Lack of variety – Repetitive routines cause boredom.

Key Takeaway

Channeling energy and instinct is about balance—physical exercise, mental challenges, and purposeful tasks.  When you provide these, your herding dog will be happier, healthier, and easier to train for advanced herding work.

Chapter 6: Advanced Herding Techniques – From Basics to Mastery

Once your herding dog has mastered obedience and focus, it’s time to introduce advanced skills that transform instinct into precision.  These techniques are essential for working with livestock safely and efficiently and also form the foundation of competitive herding trials.

Why Advanced Training Matters

Herding is not just about chasing sheep; it involves control, direction, and calm movement.

Advanced training ensures:

  • Your dog responds instantly to commands at a distance.
  • Livestock remains calm and uninjured.
  • You maintain complete control in open fields or complex environments.

Step 1: Introducing Livestock Safely

  • Start Small: Begin with 3–5 calm sheep in a small pen.
  • Controlled Observation: Allow your dog to watch livestock before interacting with them.
  • Leash or Long Line: Use for initial sessions to prevent uncontrolled chasing.
  • Short Sessions: 5–10 minutes to avoid overstimulation.

Tip: Always supervise closely—never leave a novice dog alone with livestock.

Step 2: Directional Commands

Directional cues are the language of herding.  Teach these gradually:

  • Come By – Move clockwise around the flock.
  • Away to Me – Move counterclockwise.
  • Lie down – Stop and wait.
  • Walk Up – Approach livestock slowly.
  • Stand – Pause without lying down.

Training Method:

  • Use a long line at first for control.
  • Pair verbal commands with body signals (arm gestures).
  • Reward calm, correct movement immediately.

Step 3: Whistle Training

Whistles allow control at long distances:

  • Assign distinct whistle tones for each command.
  • Practice in a quiet area before using livestock.
  • Gradually increase the distance as your dog responds reliably.

Why Whistles?  They carry farther than voice commands and remain consistent under stress.

Step 4: Expanding Complexity

Once your dog responds well:

  • Move to larger pens and increase livestock numbers.
  • Practice flanking (circling to control movement).
  • Introduce the concepts of fetching (bringing livestock toward you) and driving (moving livestock away).

Goal: Smooth, controlled movement without panic or aggression.

Step 5: Herding Trials and Real-World Work

For competitive or professional work:

  • Learn trial rules and patterns.
  • Practice precision tasks like penning and shedding (separating animals).
  • Build endurance for long sessions.

Safety and Ethics

  • Never allow rough handling or excessive nipping.
  • Keep livestock stress to a minimum.
  • End sessions on a positive note for both the dog and the animals.

Common Challenges

  • Overexcitement: Use a calm voice and frequent breaks.
  • Ignoring Commands: Reinforce obedience before herding.
  • Chasing Instead of Herding: Redirect with commands and reward calm behavior.

Key Takeaway

Advanced herding techniques transform instinct into skill.  With patience, consistency, and clear communication, your dog will become a confident, reliable partner capable of managing livestock with precision and care.

Chapter 7: Troubleshooting Common Issues – Keeping Training on Track

Even with the best preparation, herding dog training can present challenges.  These dogs are intelligent, energetic, and instinct-driven, which means they can develop habits that interfere with progress.  This chapter addresses the most common problems and offers practical solutions.

1.  Overexcitement Around Livestock

Symptoms: Barking excessively, lunging, or frantic circling when near sheep or other animals.

Causes:

  • Lack of impulse control training.
  • Too much stimulation too soon.

Solutions:

  • Start with Observation: Let your dog watch livestock from a distance before interaction.
  • Impulse Control Exercises: Practice “Lie Down” and “Stay” away from animals.
  • Short Sessions: Keep initial herding work under 10 minutes.
  • Calm Reinforcement: Use a quiet voice and reward relaxed behavior.

2.  Nipping at Heels

Symptoms: The dog aggressively bites or pinches livestock’s legs.

Causes:

  • Overactive herding instinct.
  • Lack of a clear stop command.

Solutions:

  • Teach “Lie Down” and “Stand”: Use these commands to interrupt nipping.
  • Redirect Energy: Offer a toy or ball after a successful stop.
  • Consistency: Never allow nipping to go unchecked—it can injure animals.

3.  Ignoring Commands

Symptoms: Dog refuses to respond, especially at a distance.

Causes:

  • Weak foundation training.
  • Distractions overpower obedience.

Solutions:

  • Reinforce Basics: Return to obedience drills in a quiet area.
  • Use Long Line: Maintain control during early herding sessions.
  • Whistle Training: Introduce whistle cues for long-distance reliability.

4.  Chasing Instead of Herding

Symptoms: The dog runs wildly after livestock without control.

Causes:

  • Instinct unchecked by training.
  • Lack of directional command knowledge.

Solutions:

  • Teach Directional Commands: “Come By,” “Away to Me,” and “Lie Down.”
  • Controlled Practice: Start in a small pen with a few animals.
  • Reward Calm Movement: Praise and treat when the dog slows and controls.

5.  Fear or Aggression Toward Livestock

Symptoms: The dog avoids other animals or reacts aggressively toward them.

Causes:

  • Poor socialization.
  • Negative past experiences.

Solutions:

  • Gradual Exposure: Begin with calm livestock at a distance.
  • Positive Association: Pair livestock presence with treats and praise.
  • Professional Help: For severe aggression, consult a herding trainer.

6.  Handler Frustration, consistency, and calm leadership will overcome most challenges.  Remember: herding dogs thrive on clear communication and structured training.